Choose your branch

Give

Give to a worker

  • Give
    A
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Adam and Helane Ramsay
    Japan • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Adrian and Anita Lovell
    Bolivia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Amy Stephens
    Argentina • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Andrew Buchanan and Abi Tandiseru
    Indonesia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Andrew and Margie Newman
    Uganda • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Angelica (Mentac)
    • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Arthur and Tamie Davis
    Tanzania • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    B
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • WA Branch
  • Give
    Bruce and Libby
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Bryan and Sarah Haro Leon
    • TAS Branch
  • Give
    C
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Chenny Thie
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Chris and Erin
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Chris and Grace Adams
    Timor-Leste • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Chris and Karen Webb
    North Australia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Chris and Kristy Galea
    Malta • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Chris and Stef Overhall
    Chile • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Christopher and Julie Dean
    Timor-Leste • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Colin and Catherine Puffett
    France • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Craig and Lisse
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Craig and Samantha McCorkindale
    Cambodia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    D and T
    East Asia • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Dan and Marg
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Daniel and Kate Morris
    France • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Daniel and Olivia Webster
    Namibia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Daniel (Mentac)
    • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Dave and Leoni Painter
    Cambodia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    David and Beck McIntyre
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    David and Cathie Sandifer
    Netherlands • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    David and Jennifer Juniper
    Democratic Republic of Congo • WA Branch
  • Give
    David and Prue Boyd
    Democratic Republic of Congo • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Dene and Rachel Hughes
    Japan • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Derek and Rosemary Snibson
    North Australia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Derk and Susan
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • WA Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    E
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    E
    East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Elizabeth
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Elle Bryce
    Japan • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Faraj and Emily (Mentac)
    • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Frances Cook
    Chile • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Gillian Law
    Italy • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Gordon and Ruth
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Howard and Michelle Newby
    Philippines • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Howard and Trisha Spencer
    Belgium • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    I
    South East Asia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Ian and Jenny Wood
    North Australia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Ian and Narelle Hadfield
    Singapore • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    J and P
    Eurasia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    J and S
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    J
    South East Asia • WA Branch
  • Give
    Jo
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Je
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Jason and Hannah Fairclough
    Italy • WA Branch
  • Give
    Jeremy and Jill Horrocks
    Cambodia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Jim and Tanja French
    Spain • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Joel and Tiffanie Atwood
    Vanuatu • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Joel and Aimee (Mentac)
    • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    John and Deb
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Jon and Deborah
    South East Asia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Josh and Nici
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Josh and Steph Mackenzie
    North Australia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Josh and Susannah Apieczonek
    France • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Jotham Booker (CoMP)
    Germany • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Julie
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    K
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • TAS Branch
  • Give
    K
    South East Asia • SA & NT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Karen
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Karina Brabham
    France • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Keith and Marion Birchley
    Papua New Guinea • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Kellie Nicholas
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Klaus and Jude Hickel
    Germany • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Kylie Zietsch
    South Africa • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    L and C
    South East Asia • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    M and K
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    M
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • QLD & NNSW Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    M
    Africa • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Maggie Crewes
    Cambodia • SA & NT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Malcolm and Ainsley Purdey
    Chile • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Malcolm and Charissa Forrest
    Jordan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Malcolm and Leanne
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Martin and Julie Field
    Argentina • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Marty and Jenny Foord
    Singapore • WA Branch
  • Give
    Matt and Kate Vinicombe
    North Australia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Matt and Bex Ooi
    Japan • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Matt and Jen Lim
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Matt and Lisa Pearson
    North Australia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Matt and Ellen Tyler
    Vanuatu • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Matthew and Melissa Lindfield Seager
    Cambodia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Maurice and Amanda Jacobson
    Cambodia • TAS Branch
  • Give
    Michael and Rani Grivas-Allison
    Belgium • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Mike and Karen Roe
    South Africa • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Mike and Katie Taylor
    Tanzania • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Miriam Bradshaw
    Spain • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Morgan and Olivia
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Na
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Ne
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Nathan and Diane Lovell
    South Africa • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Nathan and Maki Clapham
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Nick and Kysha Davies
    Peru • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Nick and Rebekah
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Norm and Janelle Gorrie
    Kenya • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Pedro and Joy Oliveira Woolmer
    Latin America • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Peter and Terry Blowes
    Argentina • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    R
    Eurasia • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Ray and Sandy
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Rebekah
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Rowan
    South East Asia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Ryan and Lynne Verghese
    Seychelles • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    S and M
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    S and P
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • WA Branch
  • Give
    Sam and Shan-Shan Chrisp
    Taiwan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Sam and Sharmila (CoMP)
    • WA Branch
  • Give
    Simon and Jessica Cowell
    Italy • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Steven and Sandra Parsons
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Tim and Olivia Mulherin
    Cambodia • VIC Branch
  • Give
    Tim and Sam
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Warwick and Caroline
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Zoe Creelman
    North Australia • VIC Branch

General Worker Support

Select a Branch

Please select the branch you would like to give to. This refers to the CMS branch that will process your donation.

NSW & ACT

QLD & NNSW

SA & NT

TAS

VIC

WA

Australia

Tax-deductible Workers and Projects

Select a Branch

Please select the branch you would like to give to. This refers to the CMS branch that will process your donation.

NSW & ACT

QLD & NNSW

SA & NT

TAS

VIC

WA

Australia

Give to a Campaign

Select a Branch

Please select the branch you would like to give to. This refers to the CMS branch that will process your donation.

NSW & ACT

QLD & NNSW

SA & NT

TAS

VIC

WA

Australia

  • Give
    Aboriginal Missionary Work
    Tax Deductible • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    CMS Overseas Aid Fund
    Tax Deductible • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Indigenous Ministry in North Australia
    NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Aboriginal Missionary Work
    Tax Deductible • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    CMS Overseas Aid Fund
    Tax Deductible • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Indigenous Ministry in North Australia
    SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Aboriginal Missionary Work
    Tax Deductible • WA Branch
  • Give
    CMS Overseas Aid Fund
    Tax Deductible • WA Branch
  • Give
    Indigenous Ministry in North Australia
    WA Branch
  • Give
    Go to: QLD & NNSW Campaigns
    QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Go to: VIC Campaigns
    VIC Branch
  • Give
    Go to: TAS Campaigns
    TAS Branch
  • Give
    Christmas Campaign
    VIC Branch
  • Zoe Creelman
    north-australia • australia Branch

Give to another worker from

  • Give
    A
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Adrian and Anita Lovell
    Bolivia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Amy Stephens
    Argentina • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Andrew Buchanan and Abi Tandiseru
    Indonesia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Angelica (Mentac)
    • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Arthur and Tamie Davis
    Tanzania • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    B
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • WA Branch
  • Give
    C
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Chenny Thie
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Chris and Erin
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Chris and Karen Webb
    North Australia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Chris and Kristy Galea
    Malta • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Chris and Stef Overhall
    Chile • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Colin and Catherine Puffett
    France • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Craig and Lisse
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Craig and Samantha McCorkindale
    Cambodia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Dan and Marg
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Daniel and Kate Morris
    France • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Daniel and Olivia Webster
    Namibia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Dave and Leoni Painter
    Cambodia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    David and Beck McIntyre
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    David and Cathie Sandifer
    Netherlands • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    David and Jennifer Juniper
    Democratic Republic of Congo • WA Branch
  • Give
    Derk and Susan
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • WA Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    E
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Elizabeth
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Faraj and Emily (Mentac)
    • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Frances Cook
    Chile • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Gordon and Ruth
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Howard and Michelle Newby
    Philippines • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Howard and Trisha Spencer
    Belgium • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Ian and Jenny Wood
    North Australia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Ian and Narelle Hadfield
    Singapore • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    J and P
    Eurasia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    J
    South East Asia • WA Branch
  • Give
    Jo
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Je
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Jason and Hannah Fairclough
    Italy • WA Branch
  • Give
    Jeremy and Jill Horrocks
    Cambodia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Jim and Tanja French
    Spain • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Joel and Tiffanie Atwood
    Vanuatu • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Joel and Aimee (Mentac)
    • QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Josh and Nici
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Josh and Susannah Apieczonek
    France • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Jotham Booker (CoMP)
    Germany • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Julie
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    K
    South East Asia • SA & NT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Karen
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Karina Brabham
    France • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Kellie Nicholas
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Klaus and Jude Hickel
    Germany • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Kylie Zietsch
    South Africa • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    M
    Africa • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Maggie Crewes
    Cambodia • SA & NT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Malcolm and Ainsley Purdey
    Chile • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Malcolm and Charissa Forrest
    Jordan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Malcolm and Leanne
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Martin and Julie Field
    Argentina • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Marty and Jenny Foord
    Singapore • WA Branch
  • Give
    Matt and Jen Lim
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Matt and Lisa Pearson
    North Australia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Matt and Ellen Tyler
    Vanuatu • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Matthew and Melissa Lindfield Seager
    Cambodia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Michael and Rani Grivas-Allison
    Belgium • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Mike and Karen Roe
    South Africa • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Mike and Katie Taylor
    Tanzania • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Miriam Bradshaw
    Spain • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Morgan and Olivia
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Na
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch • Tax Deductible
  • Give
    Ne
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Nathan and Diane Lovell
    South Africa • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Nathan and Maki Clapham
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Nick and Kysha Davies
    Peru • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Nick and Rebekah
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Norm and Janelle Gorrie
    Kenya • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Pedro and Joy Oliveira Woolmer
    Latin America • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Peter and Terry Blowes
    Argentina • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Ray and Sandy
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Rebekah
    South East Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Ryan and Lynne Verghese
    Seychelles • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    S and M
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    S and P
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • WA Branch
  • Give
    Sam and Shan-Shan Chrisp
    Taiwan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Sam and Sharmila (CoMP)
    • WA Branch
  • Give
    Simon and Jessica Cowell
    Italy • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Steven and Sandra Parsons
    Japan • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Tim and Sam
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Warwick and Caroline
    Middle East, South & Central Asia • NSW & ACT Branch

General Worker Support

Select a Branch

Sed non urna. Donec et ante. Phasellus eu ligula. Vestibulum sit amet purus. Vivamus hendrerit, dolor at aliquet laoreet, mauris turpis porttitor velit, faucibus interdum tellus libero ac justo. Vivamus non quam. In suscipit faucibus urna.

NSW & ACT

QLD & NNSW

SA & NT

TAS

VIC

WA

Australia

Tax-deductible Workers and Projects

Select a Branch

Please select the branch you would like to give to. This refers to the CMS branch that will process your donation.

NSW & ACT

QLD & NNSW

SA & NT

TAS

VIC

WA

Australia

Give to a Campaign

  • Give
    Aboriginal Missionary Work
    Tax Deductible • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    CMS Overseas Aid Fund
    Tax Deductible • NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Indigenous Ministry in North Australia
    NSW & ACT Branch
  • Give
    Aboriginal Missionary Work
    Tax Deductible • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    CMS Overseas Aid Fund
    Tax Deductible • SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Indigenous Ministry in North Australia
    SA & NT Branch
  • Give
    Aboriginal Missionary Work
    Tax Deductible • WA Branch
  • Give
    CMS Overseas Aid Fund
    Tax Deductible • WA Branch
  • Give
    Indigenous Ministry in North Australia
    WA Branch
  • Give
    Go to: QLD & NNSW Campaigns
    QLD & NNSW Branch
  • Give
    Go to: VIC Campaigns
    VIC Branch
  • Give
    Go to: TAS Campaigns
    TAS Branch
  • Give
    Christmas Campaign
    VIC Branch
Total Gift

$0 / Month

Continue

Checkpoint

Identity and Mission. Article Four of Six: Identity and Contextualisation

David Williams is Director of Training and Development for CMS. In this the fourth of six articles on ‘Identity and Mission’, he introduces his topic with some reflections on ‘Identity Crisis’. Article 1, ‘Identity Crisis’, is here. Article 2, ‘Identity and Mission’, is here.  Article 3, ‘Identity and Scripture’, is here.

In the first three articles in this series, I highlighted the importance of finding an identity in Christ, the way in which identity is constructed out of social relationships and the significance of finding an identity both in Christ and with His people. I ended by raising a question asked by William Dyrness: “Might not [other religions] represent potential places where Christ can be encountered and God’s project worked out?”[1]

This question lies at the heart of insider movement theology. As we have seen, when a person comes to faith in Christ from another religious context, they face a huge challenge as they establish their identity in Christ. Identity has been a central issue in the debate about C1-C6 Muslim contextualisation. The original C1-C6 article by John Travis described ways that people who were born and raised as Muslims now identified themselves, having confessed Jesus as Lord.[2] C1-3 believers identify themselves as Christians. C4 believers identify themselves as followers of Isa—they would typically not use the label Christian but would certainly not call themselves Muslims. C5 believers are those “who follow Jesus as Lord and Saviour in fellowships of like-minded believers within the Muslim community, continuing to identify culturally and officially as Muslims.”[3] C6 are secret or underground believers. These distinctions extend to the identity created as believers gather. C3 gatherings avoid any cultural forms considered Islamic. C4 gatherings include biblically permissible Islamic forms. C5 gatherings take place within Muslim contexts, including within mosques.

In earlier articles I argued that finding an identity in Christ cannot be separated from finding an identity with Christ’s people. My identity in Christ is about who I am, who I am becoming and who I belong with. However, this does not mean that finding an identity in Christ requires a person to identify as ‘Christian’—or at least not without first providing careful clarification and definition of what ‘Christian’ means. If ‘Christian’ means something like ‘alcohol-drinking, pork-eating, supporter of USA’s foreign policy’ then of course I can be in Christ without being that sort of Christian. If ‘Christian’ means appreciating liturgy, hymns and a Pastor in a dog collar, again I can be in Christ without being that sort of Christian. However, I cannot claim to be united with Christ if I am not also united with Christ’s people. The two are inseparable. This unity has an eschatological reality. However, the New Testament also expects that this unity will have an embodied, local dimension. The Hebrew Christians were expected to keep up the habit of meeting together, even though some had suffered the confiscation of their property and others had been imprisoned (Hebrews 10:19-34).

What, then, does it look like to find an identity in Christ and with Christ’s people? It looks cruciform. To be in Christ is to be united with Christ in his death and resurrection. To be with Christ’s people is to belong with those whose lives are cross-shaped. This cross-shaped community is largely defined by Scripture in terms of holiness, characterised by love, grace and the fruit of the Spirit—and is remarkably free of cultural prescriptions.[4] However, the New Testament clearly imagines that this cruciform identity involves a public confession of Christ as Lord and a genuine embodied identification with Christ’s people. So, who am I? I am united with Christ in his death and resurrection. Who am I becoming? I am becoming cruciform, daily taking up my cross to follow Jesus. Who do I belong with? I belong with a cruciform local community of fellow cross-carriers.

But let’s be clear—proponents of C5 contextualisation argue that this is possible from a C5 position. Using the C5 definition from earlier—those “who follow Jesus as Lord and Saviour in fellowships of like-minded believers within the Muslim community, continuing to identify culturally and officially as Muslims”[5]—C5 proponents might argue that Jesus has been confessed as Lord and a fellowship of like-minded believers has been joined. The question we are then left with is: “is it valid to do this while still identifying culturally and officially as Muslim?”

How we answer this question will depend on other theological themes—for example, our theology of religion, how positive or negative we are towards human cultures, and what we define as religious or cultural. The structure of Dyrness’s argument in Insider Jesus is to argue that Western theology has unhelpfully ignored creation and over-emphasised redemption; then to argue that humans are culture creators and that world religions can be an expression of humans using their God-given creativity, albeit in limited or mistaken ways; and then to argue that the God of the Bible can be found and even followed within other religions.[6]

This highlights an issue that I come across over and over again in missiology: what you think about a missiological issue depends so much on a series of prior theological decisions and commitments you have made.[7] In this case, I question the validity of making a separation between creation and redemption. As John Woodhouse points out, the creation narrative includes a focus on judgement and creation is renewed by redemption.[8] Creation and redemption are held together in Scripture, not apart. Similarly, Dyrness argues for a positive view of other religions based largely on a positive view of Judaism – but I question the validity of comparing other religions with Judaism.

However, while I have many questions about Insider Jesus, I recognise that mission needs to engage with the fundamental identity questions that believers from other religious backgrounds are asking. My provisional answer is to attempt to broaden the question from ‘who am I?’ to ‘who am I becoming and who do I belong with?’ And then to say ‘I am becoming cruciform and I belong with a cruciform people.’ I will try and flesh this out in greater detail in the next article.

 

References Cited:

Cumming, Joseph. “Muslim Followers of Jesus?”. In Understanding Insider Movements: Disciples of Jesus within Diverse Religious Communities, edited by John Jay Travis and Harley Talman. Pasadena, CA: William Carey Library, 2015.

Dyrness, William A. Insider Jesus: Theological Reflections on New Christian Movements. Downers Grove IL: InterVarsity Press, 2016.

Travis, John Jay. “Must All Muslims Leave Islam to Follow Jesus?”. Evangelical Missions Quarterly 34, no. 4 (1998): 411-15.

Woodhouse, John. “Evangelism and Social Responsibility.” In Christians in Society, 3-26. Homebush West, NSW: Lancer Books, 1988.

 

[1] William A. Dyrness, Insider Jesus: Theological Reflections on New Christian Movements (Downers Grove IL: InterVarsity Press, 2016), 67.

[2] John Jay Travis, “Must All Muslims Leave Islam to Follow Jesus?,” Evangelical Missions Quarterly 34, no. 4 (1998).

[3] Joseph Cumming, “Muslim Followers of Jesus?,” in Understanding Insider Movements: Disciples of Jesus within Diverse Religious Communities, ed. John Jay Travis and Harley Talman (Pasadena, CA: William Carey Library, 2015), 26.

[4] The New Testament records a number of significant battles around cultural prescriptions, especially freedom from circumcision and food laws.

[5] Cumming, “Muslim Followers of Jesus?,” 26.

[6] Dyrness, Insider Jesus: Theological Reflections on New Christian Movements.

[7] Which is one reason why it is so important that CMS requires our workers to complete at least a year at Bible College.

[8] John Woodhouse, “Evangelism and Social Responsibility,” in Christians in Society (Homebush West, NSW: Lancer Books, 1988), 20-21.